Layout:
Home > They Can't Save Money on an Income of $250,000 a Year

They Can't Save Money on an Income of $250,000 a Year

May 24th, 2007 at 06:46 am

I read this article today:

http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/SavingandDebt/Advice/RichDontSaveEither.aspx

and I have to say I really did not have a lot of sympathy. Even less than when I read the one about the family living on $150,000 a year and having such a hard time of it.

What is the world coming to when people can't save money on a $250,000 a year salary? Just what are they spending their money on? McMansions?

I guess I just don't get it. To me a house is a house, whether you're living in an RV park, a manufactured home, a log cabin, a garden shed, or a stick-built house. As long as it is structurally safe and is well-kept, one place is as good as the other. Maybe paying for a better neighborhood, I can see, but a home shouldn't break you. It should just be the place you hang your hat and sleep at night.

Fancy cars? Again, its transportation, it should just get you from point A to point B. As long as it is well-maintained and of a size to fit the needs of your family there is no reason for a Mercedes or even a Lexus or Lincoln Town Car if it means you can't afford your bills or to put a little something into savings.

Private schools? Even private schools don't need to break the bank. The Waldorf one here is less than $4000 a year, so it doesn't have to be some $50,000 a year perparatory academy.

I don't know. I don't know what they could be spending so much of their income on that they can't afford their bills and to save money. Even considering a hefty tax bite, I just don't get it.

Maybe they just never learn delayed gratification. I can't fathom it.

13 Responses to “They Can't Save Money on an Income of $250,000 a Year”

  1. quippymcflippy Says:
    1180007829

    Amen. I was commenting on something similar to my husband when we were out on a walk after dinner. "Is there even such thing as a new MODEST home anymore?" A bungalow that is 1500sq feet? It seems like every new house is monstrous - and with that comes increased upkeep/increased energy costs/increased everything (except maybe yard work given the postage stamp sized lawns that result). Big Grin

  2. disneysteve Says:
    1180010394

    quippy - I was just reading an article about this yesterday. The average new home today is 1.5 times as large as in 1970 and 2 times larger than in 1950. However, there is starting to be a reversal in the trend, primarily driven by aging baby boomers looking to downsize and have more manageable homes. Also, as land gets scarcer, smaller homes are coming back into vogue.

  3. Nic Says:
    1180011825

    Some people need a reality check.

  4. Aleta Says:
    1180013812

    Not only are the houses smaller, but the lot is also. I live on a zero lot line and I don't really reccommend it unless you live in a community where they have some control over noisy neighbors. We have neighbors who play their boom boom music outside and you can't hear your own TV inside even with your windows shut.

  5. monkeymama Says:
    1180015712

    Living in a high COL I tend to defend these people a bit more than I should - LOL. I mean seriously out here 1/2 of that could go to taxes and you still wouldn't be able to afford the standard $700k mortgage for a 2-bedroom fixer.

    BUT I can play the other side as well. They have choices, many many many choices that the truly poor don't have. & in general none of these people are living particularly deprived lifestyles (that I know). You know, we simply chose not to play that game, I am not going to make $150k/year just to afford a crappy house. It's that simple.

    & of course living out here where wages and COL is both higher than average, I see it a lot. You don't know how many people I thought were really bad off just to find out they make six figures. Since housing is nowhere near insane expensive up here though you just scratch your head until you realize private school, manicure/pedicure/hair done weekly, expensive name brands, big expensive new cars every couple of years, and dinner out every night - and biggest of all vacations and mini-vacations galore - you see why the six figures isn't exactly cutting it. Pretty much ALL the stuff that isn't in our budget. They'll complain about their rent too, but that doesn't exactly pull on my heartstrings considering where I am from. Rent at 10% of income sounds like a bargain to me! Since housing is relatively expensive though most people I know out here aren't sinking a lot into big homes or anything. BUT I did have a friend in her early 20s that did rent a McMansion for $2k/month. Lord knows why!!! Couldn't afford it in the least, but that is what the young 20 crowd wants and they want it now I guess. It creeps me out. She was one I thought was really bad off before, but later found out makes six figures, just bought a new truck, had a 4th unexpected child, and has 2 kids in private school. Oy vey. I was very generous at her last 2 baby showers, and then I got fed up and skipped the last one - what a racket. I used to feel bad for her and want to help her out as a young mom. Now I just have to roll my eyes. Why am I trying to help her out when I make 1/2 as much? LOL. But I see this over and over and over around here.

  6. Ima saver Says:
    1180018612

    Well, I do live in a pretty big house, 3200 sq. feet and I love it. However, every house since my first house, has been fully paid for and we have lived on an income of under $50,000 a year for a long time. (More like $20,000 a year 20 years ago.
    Luckily, we have pretty cheap property tax too and my electric bill is usually under $100 a month.

  7. homebody Says:
    1180107627

    I used to work for a doctor and paid his household bills. I always said the rich were just as broke as us...just at a higher standard of living...

  8. disneysteve Says:
    1180187505

    homebody - That's true, and something that many people simply don't understand. Obviously, when those with higher incomes are struggling, it is usually their own doing. Overspending, keeping up with the Joneses, etc. I'm a physician and never allowed myself to fall into that trap. I don't feel the need to drive a "doctor's" car or live in a "doctor's" house or send my kid to private school with all the other doctor's kids. In fact, our frugality led to me and my family being profiled in a national magazine several years ago. It is a financial magazine geared toward physicians. The article focused on how we live below our means, do a lot of home cooking, drive modest cars, shop at thrift shops, take budget vacations, etc. All things that are not usually associated with high-income professionals. The article also listed our assets and investment portfolio, which was well above average for our age at the time.

  9. homebody Says:
    1180291427

    Mmmm Disneysteve, did I read that article and why have you not shared this with us before now??!! Ha Ha!

  10. LuckyRobin Says:
    1180300739

    Steve, I don't suppose there is an old link to that article floating around somewhere, is there? I'd think it would make for a very good read.

  11. disneysteve Says:
    1180355918

    homebody and LuckyRobin - The article can be found, but I've always hesitated to post it because it gives my full name, town, etc. Kind of trashes the whole online anonymous thing. Maybe I'll pull it up and edit out the identifying things and post it to my blog.

  12. disneysteve Says:
    1180357014

    Okay folks. I've edited and posted the article to my blog. Comments are welcomed.

  13. Sarah Says:
    1291349259

    It makes no sense what this country has come to, people don't want to live within or below their means. If you want to build wealth don't get in debt, me and my husband saved to buy our 4 br, 3 ba home for $170,000. It took us 5 yrs staying in cheap rent but we did it,we spend money that wold have gone to a mortgage in our savings account, we have more than $650,000 saved. We eat out once a month,I never buy leading brands I only buy store brands, we both buy and drive used cars.

Leave a Reply

(Note: If you were logged in, we could automatically fill in these fields for you.)
*
Will not be published.
   

* Please spell out the number 4.  [ Why? ]

vB Code: You can use these tags: [b] [i] [u] [url] [email]